Naive vs Deliberate Practice

Hi friends! Please reply to this message if you’re coming to class in the morning. Feel free to let me know whatever I might need to know in the note.

You’re also welcome to chat and share here! ok — onward!

Why Just Showing Up Isn’t Enough (But Still Counts for Something)

Anyone who’s spent more than a week in an Ashtanga shala knows the truth: repetition doesn’t guarantee evolution. You can do the same vinyasa a thousand times and still land like a sack of coconuts. The difference between “going through the motions” and “growing through the motions” is what psychologists call the gap between naïve practice and deliberate practice.

Naïve Practice: The Autopilot Trap

Naïve practice is when you just do the thing over and over, assuming that repetition alone will create mastery. It’s the “10,000 hours” myth taken out for a lazy spin. In this mode, you might be faithful, consistent, and sweaty—but not necessarily getting better. Why? Because the brain loves efficiency. Once it figures out a pattern that’s “good enough,” it automates it. From that point on, you’re not really learning; you’re rehearsing your current limitations.

In yoga terms: you might hit the same jump-through every day for three years, with the same breath holding, the same shoulder shrug, the same grunt of mild despair. You’re getting stronger, sure, but not necessarily more skillful. You’re refining endurance, not awareness.

Psychologist Anders Ericsson—the researcher who coined the term—described deliberate practice as “repeated performance with attentive refinement based on feedback.” You don’t just clock hours; you mine them for data. You use that data to rewire your system, millimeter by millimeter.

In Ashtanga Context

Naïve practice might say, “Just do your practice.” Deliberate practice says, “Do your practice and watch your practice doing you.” The Ashtanga method—when applied consciously—is already a built-in feedback system: breath, drishti, bandha, and vinyasa form a loop of awareness. When that loop is alive, your practice becomes self-correcting. When it’s dull, it becomes habit dressed as devotion.

Gregor Maehle often reminds us that asana is a laboratory for self-knowledge. You’re not just training muscles; you’re training perception. The goal isn’t perfect form but perfect attention. In that sense, deliberate practice is the living pulse of the method—the heart of what Patanjali called abhyasa (steady effort in the direction of freedom).